Caffeine, a good diet and a drink a day: mental clarity

by Mark Miller August 24, 2017

caffeine and memory

Albert Anker's 1891 painting "Still Life with Coffee, Bread and Potatoes" shows some of what may go into a positive diet for mental improvement: caffeine and wholesome foods. (Public Domain)

It seems caffeine may enhance memory and learning, but not if it is taken before the lesson is to be learned. Research from a few years ago says caffeine should be taken after that important business meeting, crucial college lecture or other knowledge-imparting event you need to recall.

Some studies show a benefit from caffeine on memory, some show none. Same with alcohol. But it seems scientists find with few exceptions that good diets promote healthy minds and bodies.

Caffeine and memory

Researchers led by Daniel Borota from the Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland, published a study in 2014 in the journal Nature Neuroscience stated in their abstract, "We conclude that caffeine enhanced consolidation of long-term memories in humans."

It was a complicated study in which 160 healthy women age 18 to 30 performed what a blog on Scientific American's website calls "a series of learning tasks."

Scientific American summarizes how the study was conducted:

The subjects were handed cards with pictures of various random indoor and outdoor objects (for instance leaves, ducks and handbags) on them and asked to classify the objects as indoor or outdoor. Immediately after the task the volunteers were handed pills, either containing 200 mg of caffeine or placebo. Saliva samples to test for caffeine and its metabolites were collected after 1, 3 and 24 hours.

After 24 hours the researchers tested the participants' recollection of the past day's test. Along with the items in the test ('old') they were presented with new items ('foils') and similar looking items ('lures'), neither of which were part of the task. They were then asked to again classify the items as old, new and similar. There was a statistically significant percentage of volunteers in the caffeinated group that was more likely to mark the 'similar' items as 'similar' rather than 'old'. That is, caffeinated participants were clearly able to distinguish much better between the old and the other items, indicating that they were retaining the memory of the old items much better than the people in the placebo group.

The authors attempted to differentiate between memory retrieval and consolidation by doing another test. Participants were given caffeine one hour before a learning task on the second day. There were no statistical differences between the placebo and caffeine subjects between a 200 mg dose and the 300 mg dose. There was a finding that 200 mg helped memory more than 100, however, suggesting a minimum dose is needed. The author said this warrants more study.

Caffeine, diet, alcohol

The Harvard Medical School blog had a 2015 posting citing some research that said diet and alcohol and caffeine may play a role in memory. That blog states:

If a study published in this month's Journal of Nutrition is any indication, the caffeine in coffee might offer not just a momentary mental boost but also longer-term effects on thinking skills. Having an alcoholic drink a day might also benefit our mental performance, but the line between just right and too much is uncertain. An even better strategy for maintaining memory and thinking skills with age may be to eat a healthy diet.

In the study, researchers from the National Institute on Aging compared scores on various tests of thinking skills and memory with caffeine, alcohol, and nutrient intake in 727 men and women taking part in the Baltimore Longitudinal Study of Aging. Over all, participants who ranked high on the healthy diet scale did better on 10 tests of memory than those with lower diet scores. The same held true for those who took in more caffeine. The effects for moderate alcohol drinking were mixed.

But if you are older and were hoping you might retain your memory better with a daily dose of caffeine, it does not appear to help, according to one study.

"The Journal of Nutrition study isn't the last word on the subject of caffeine and memory," Harvard Health writes. "It showed that people, particularly those who were ages 70 and over, who took in more caffeine scored better on tests of mental function, but not on memory tests or other measures of mental ability."

'Quick wakeup call'

Harvard writes that the brain gets a "quick wakeup call after chugging a mug of coffee." The author says caffeine is believed to trick the brain because it is a stimulant in itself and because it blocks adenosine receptors, which normally prevent the brain from releasing more stimulating chemicals. When adenosine is blocked, the brain exciters are produced in greater numbers, giving a burst of energy and perhaps improving cognition.

It's important to note what Harvard says about these studies: "Some previous studies have shown improved long-term memory performance and thinking ability in regular caffeine consumers; others haven't shown any connection."

Benefits from drinking alcohol came only when men had no more than two drinks per day and women one drink per day. More than that and people suffer brain damage and short-term memory loss. One or two drinks a day improved working memory and attention.

Diet and cognition

It makes sense that this study found a good diet improved mental performance. Harvard wrote:

People who ate foods with plenty of healthful nutrients had better attention and memory than participant with poorer diets. A healthy diet was also linked to good thinking skills in women and participants under age 70. In particular, foods that are part of the Mediterranean diet, fruits, vegetables, nuts, fish, olive oil, and whole grains, show promise for preserving memory and preventing Alzheimer's and other forms of dementia. This study is just one of many linking healthy eating habits with maintaining memory and thinking skills into old age. Continuing a healthy diet, or switching to one, makes sense on many levels. It probably is good for your brain, and it's definitely good for your heart, bones, muscles, and overall health.

In terms of memory loss or enhancement, caffeine, diet and drinking, it seems like age-old common sense is a good guide: a lot of good things, but all in moderation.
Mark Miller
Mark Miller

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.

Also in The Viter Energy Mints Blog

depression and caffeine
Depression and Caffeine - Is it good or bad?

by Mark Miller October 23, 2017

The effects of caffeine on one's mental state are an important area for scientists to explore because about 90 percent of the world's adults take the stimulating substance. Some prefer coffee, some tea, some soda pop and others take it in energy drinks. Caffeine is also in chocolate, some over-the-counter pain relievers and other products, including Viter Energy Mints.

As to depression and caffeine, some scientists say it helps alleviate symptoms, and some say it causes depression to worsen. Some claim caffeine's positive effects are so great that it can help prevent suicide.

Read More
caffeine and dehydration
Does too much coffee cause dehydration?

by Mark Miller October 17, 2017

Scientists have been studying whether eight 8-ounce glasses are necessary, and whether moderate amounts of caffeine make you dehydrated. The answers: no and no.

It was claimed caffeine makes you urinate so much you become dehydrated. In fact, taken in moderate amounts, caffeinated beverages can contribute to your overall daily water needs. Drink up, but beware you might have to go to the bathroom a lot.

Read More
does caffeine stunt growth
Great news: Caffeine doesn’t stunt growth

by Mark Miller October 10, 2017

Does caffeine stunt growth? A lot of people may say that, but the science doesn't support the contention. It's an urban legend now. About 90 percent of Americans consume caffeine in one product or another.

Caffeine is the world's most popular stimulant. It and coffee are legal, and in moderate doses do no harm but actually may help people by decreasing the risk of several conditions.

Read More