Does caffeine stunt growth?

April 28, 2020 4 min read

Does caffeine stunt growth?

About 90 percent of Americans consume caffeine in one product or another.

Caffeine is the world’s most popular stimulant. In moderate doses, it does no harm but actually may help people by decreasing the risk of several conditions.

In fact, caffeine has some surprising health benefits.

Despite this, several myths about coffee abound. One of them is this:

Does caffeine stunt growth?

Is there truth to this? Or is this a mere urban legend?

 

WHERE THE WHOLE FUSS CAME FROM

The concern about coffee causing stunted growth goes back at least to the 16th century, when it was banned in Mecca, Saudi Arabia, for health reasons. King Charles of England banned coffee in 1675 for similar health concerns.

In more modern times, the hysteria over coffee goes back to C.W. Post of Post breakfast cereals and other foods, who also manufactured Postum, a grain-based drink for breakfast time.

Image from Smithsonian Magazine

 

Postum became popular and the advertising of it was aimed at parents who were told caffeine damages children. Postum was advertised as a coffee alternative without caffeine.

Mark Pregendergast wrote Uncommon Grounds: The History of Coffee and How It Transformed Our World. He told Smithsonian: [1]

“Postum made C.W. Post a fortune, and he became a millionaire from vilifying coffee, and saying how horrible it was for you. The Postum advertisers had all kinds of pseudoscientific reasons that you should stay away from coffee.”

Post ascribed kidney and heart dysfunction, nervousness and indigestion to coffee. He said it also led to sallow skin. Post died in 1914, but even thereafter ads for Postum said children should never be given coffee because it makes them sluggish, sleepless, irritable and robbed them of rosy cheek and sparkling eyes. Plus, the ads said, it hampers proper development and growth.

“To my knowledge, no one has ever turned up evidence that drinking coffee has any effect on how much children grow,” Pregenderast said.

Since then, parents have been reluctant to submit their children to drinking coffee every day.

 

THE REAL DEAL

Caffeine causing stunted growth may not necessarily be gospel truth for a variety of reasons:

 

Height is determined by genes, your diet, and overall health.

Harvard Health tackles the question of caffeine and stunting and says: [2]

Whether or not coffee turns out to have significant health benefits, this popular beverage doesn’t stunt your growth. Your height is largely determined by the height of your parents and the quality of your diet and overall health while growing. If you eat a balanced diet and take measures to avoid osteoporosis, you’re likely to achieve the maximum height “allowed” by your genes. And, sorry: Just as drinking coffee won’t make you shorter, avoiding it won’t make you any taller.

Caffeine does NOT cause osteoporosis

Harvard says the belief held by some people that coffee stunts growth may come from a debunked claim that it causes osteoporosis or a decrease in bone mass or density. Osteoporosis can shorten people if there are compression fractures of the spine. But the fractures are what cause height loss, not the osteoporosis in and of itself. Still, osteoporosis does not routinely cause people to become shorter.

Years ago, some studies reported a heightened risk of osteoporosis among coffee drinkers. The studies said caffeine stimulates the body to eliminate calcium, which can be a factor in osteoporosis.

There was some alarm over this because millions of coffee drinkers could be at risk for calcium loss leading to osteoporosis. But the loss of calcium from caffeine consumption was small. Also, a link between osteoporosis and coffee was never substantiated.

Harvard Health reports:

In fact, when the studies suggesting a link were analyzed, it turned out that people who drank more coffee drank less milk and other calcium-containing beverages. So it was probably the dietary intake of calcium and vitamin D among coffee drinkers, not the coffee, that increased the risk of osteoporosis.

Harvard advises people who may have lingering uneasiness about calcium loss from coffee to take calcium and vitamin D supplements or to get them in their diets.

 

Pre-teens normally do NOT drink coffee

There is another fact that strikes down the coffee stunts growth idea: Most people attain their maximum height in their late teens, well before they start drinking coffee habitually.

 

Caffeine can mess up your sleep, which can affect growth

There may be some link, but caffeine does NOT directly stunt growth.

The correlation, however, may be found in what caffeine does to your central nervous system and anxiety levels.

As a stimulant, caffeine affects the central nervous system. A cup or two a day would normally be okay but going beyond that would bring out caffeine’s bad side effects. Too many caffeinated drinks may cause jitters, anxiety, and dizziness, which could all mess up your normal sleeping patterns. And lack of quality sleep leads to stunted growth in the long-term, especially for children.

 

WHAT THE STUDIES SAY

Aside for the above mentioned reasons, a number of studies have supported the claim that caffeine does NOT hinder you from getting taller:

  • A study followed 81 women aged 12-18 years old for six years and found no evidence in caffeine’s impact on bone health or density. The study reported no difference in quality of bone health between people with the highest and lowest caffeine intake. [3
  • While early researchers found a link between caffeine intake and a decrease in calcium absorption [456], the change is considered insignificant. In fact, the reduction in calcium absorption can easily be fixed with 1-2 tablespoons of milk added to every 6-ounce/180ml cup of coffee. [7]
  • A series of studies involving women aged 65 to 77 who drank about 18 ounces of coffee daily experienced notable bone loss over a three-year period compared to those who didn't. But these results were only experienced by subjects with unusual variations in their vitamin D cell receptors. It turns out that these effects were easily offset by taking the recommended daily allowance of 1,200 mg of calcium. [8]
     

    Sources

    [1] https://www.businessinsider.com/no-evidence-that-coffee-stunts-growth-2013-12

    [2] https://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/can-coffee-really-stunt-your-growth

    [3] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/9791842

    [4] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/2402180

    [5] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1553855

    [6] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/7599455

    [7] https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12204390

    [8] https://science.howstuffworks.com/innovation/edible-innovations/coffee-stunt-growth.htm

    Tina Sendin
    Tina Sendin



    Also in Viter Energy Blog

    You can't get rid the body of caffeine quickly
    You can't get rid the body of caffeine quickly

    March 02, 2021 5 min read

    It’s not possible to eliminate caffeine from the body more quickly than usual. Caffeine’s half-life, the time it takes to for a healthy adult to see a reduction of caffeine’s presence in the body by half, is 5.7 hours.
    And if you don’t get your usual dose the next day, you may go into minor withdrawal and be groggy and cross. Some people also experience a headache if they don’t get their usual dose.

     

    Some people go to extraordinary lengths to eliminate caffeine, including doing vigorous exercise and taking cleansing or detoxification measures. These measures are not likely to reduce caffeine’s presence in your body at all. Be patient, the last traces of caffeine should be gone completely about a day after ingestion.

    Read More
    How bad is caffeine withdrawal? What causes it?
    How bad is caffeine withdrawal? What causes it?

    February 25, 2021 5 min read

    How bad is caffeine withdrawal? People who have a caffeine habit may empathize with a scene of the 1931 production of Frankenstein, in which the mad scientist exults over the animation of his monster, exclaiming “It’s alive! It’s a alive, it’s alive!” I know I get animated in the morning after drinking my first cup of the ichor we call coffee.

    Caffeinated products are wildly popular worldwide, used by as much as 90 percent of the adult population. An estimated 80 percent of American adults take caffeine in one product or another, and it’s estimated half of those people are prone to headaches for one reason or another. If you are among the caffeine users who get caffeine withdrawal headaches from coffee, tea or energy drinks, there are a few things you can do to minimize the pain.

    Read More
    Benefits of coffee
    How well studied is caffeine?

    February 23, 2021 5 min read

    Studies of caffeine show that it does not increase the risk of death, but it causes a habit or possibly a dependence that the American Psychiatric Association now lists in its diagnosis manual as a disorder that warrants more study.

    Scientists study caffeine and its use by humans a lot, some say more than any other psychoactive substance in the world. Caffeine is the most widely used drug, and more scientists are saying now there should be yet more studies into dependence and other aspects of caffeine consumption.

    Read More